’tis the end of the recommendation-writing season….and you’ve gotta love the English…

….maybe that title needs a wee bit of an explanation.

To enrol in the the Engineering program at Ecole Polytechnique, candidates first suffer through a gruelling delightful “Classe Préparatoire” — roughly 2 or 3 years of “undergraduate maths, physics, and science” — then they sit an exhaustive and competitive entrance exam.

If they’re among the 400 best at that entrance exam, we let them in … keep them for 3 years … and then kick them out.

If they want to actually get the Ecole Polytechnique engineering degree (and they do…) they must show that they can also make it elsewhere: go do a Masters in some (often, foreign) university. When they come back and show us their Masters degree, then we will hand them also the Polytechnique degree – usually in a very festive graduation ceremony.

So, being on faculty at Ecole Polytechnique also means helping students find a good place to do their Masters, and to help them get admitted to it – which includes “writing recommendation letters”. In the 21th century, most of this is an on-line exercise with forms to fill and PDFs to upload…

…and this is where you gotta love the English. More specifically, you’ve gotta love Oxbridge…where it is automatically assumed that an academic referee, of course, might be properly styled Baron, Group Captain, Her Royal Highness, and …. Herr (???). And, where the admissions office (and, their web designers) wouldn’t be caught dead not offering the proper form of address.

I’ll admit, it has been very hard to resist the temptation to select “Baroness” or “Bishop”….


  1. Well, you could reasonably pretend to the title of “baron of networking” (baroness if you wish also, none of my business… ) or even a “Bishop of IETF” 😉

    • I believe that “Bishop of the IETF” is the correct term for IESG members – and a term not to be taken in vain by random protocol wonks.

  2. They seem to have forgotten the proper address for a Pope (and no I don’t know what the Pope of the IETF might be, or even if such a position exist ^^

    • I would guess that the IETF equivalent of a “pope” would be the IAB or IESG chairs – for which proper form of address is “hey you…!” I think 😉

      • But what would happen if someone from got a recommandation letter from Pope Francis (whose proper form of address is His Holiness).

Comments are closed.